 |
| They paid well -OFF! |
A younger Dustin, during his summer days while an undergrad, worked for a promotional company that would send him around various parts of Cincinnati touting all the latest and greatest products. One of the first companies that acquired my talents was OFF! insect repellent, who hired me to walk around Cincinnati Zoo while handing out coupons and making sure kids didn't kill themselves in the 'Bug Jump'. One of the most common questions I would get from people I would talk to about the product was how OFF! works to repel those pesky summer insects? You may know the active ingredient in a majority of insect repellents is the chemical N,N-Diethyl-meta-toluamide, more commonly known as DEET.
While known to be a repellent, the actual mechanism for DEET's actions is poorly understood. There have been two schools of thought as to how volatile DEET affects an insects behavior: the first, is that DEET interferes with an insects olfactory system to block host odor recognition or secondly, that DEET will repel insects by activating olfactory neurons that control avoidance behavior. A recent paper published in
Nature by Pellegrino et al. sought to gain some insights into DEET's mode of action.
The work performed on
Drosophila melanogaster (DEET is known to deter
Drosophila from their food source also) began looking at how DEET interacts with the
olfactory system and how that subsequently affects their behavior. It's been
known for a few years that the behavioral effects of DEET require the olfactory system to be functional, which also must contain the olfactory co-receptor
ORCO. While this does implicate the olfactory system in the behavioral effects, it still doesn't rule out either of the competing ideas mentioned above, nor does it answer whether DEET acts on the odor-specific odorant receptors, ORCO or both. To answer these questions the authors performed electrophysiological recordings of the flies olfactory neurons(OSN). What they discovered was that upon testing four known olfactory neurons with ten diverse odors, the effects of DEET on each were complex and dependent on the receptor, the odor, and the concentration. In some cases, the DEET suppressed odor-mediated inhibition, in others it decreased odor-induced activation of the neurons and lastly, in some it had no effect. Surprising to me was that DEET alone (without presentation of another odor) caused no response in two of the four neurons. This--along with some data that I won't mention--seems to support a hypothesis that DEET is a molecular confusant, it scrambles the odor code by the direct modulation of the receptor activity, depending on the type of odor and the concentration.
The authors believed that because the results varied in all of the neurons, an because ORCO is expressed in each, that DEET's effects are unlikely due to sole interactions with ORCO. What they found was that DEET was able to modulate and interfere with the odor specific odorant receptor subunit, OR59B. Further investigation revealed that a strain of Drosophila found in Brazil, Boa Esperança, was insensitive to DEET and was found to have
polymorphisms within the OR59B that differed from other strains assayed. They were then able to show that one of those genetic polymorphisms, a valine to alanine substitution, when introduced into their control strains was able to
phenocopy the Boa Esperança insensitivity, showing that a single polymorphism within the OR59B could render an insect insensitive to DEET's effects. Isn't evolution fun?
So there you have it, DEET modulates it's effects by activation and inhibition of an insects olfactory system through direct interaction with an odor receptor. DEET does not actually repeal, or scare away pest insects once you apply it, but once mixed with your "I'm food, come suck my blood" smell it acts to confuse the insects.
One example that has been stated is that if DEET worked on us, it would be like being hungry and seeing a giant stack of hamburgers, but the hamburgers no longer smell like hamburgers to you.
mmmmmm hamburgers.......
As always, cheers to Pellegrino and the rest of the group.